Skip to main content

Judicial Impeachment


  1. How much of the House must agree to impeach a judge? How much of the Senate must agree to remove a judge?
    A majority of the house (at least 1/2) is needed to approve an indictment to impeach, and a and a 2/3 supermajority of the Senate must convict the judge for him or her to be removed.
  2. Has this process ever been used before for the Supreme Court?  How many times?
    This process has been used for the Supreme Court before. Only one Supreme Court justice, Samuel Chase, has ever been impeached, and the motion to impeach him was part of a motion by Jefferson's Democratic-Republicans to remove a political enemy, though ultimately he was acquitted.
  3. Where in the Constitution does it set up the impeachment process?
    Article II, Section 4 of the Constitution allows the President, Vice President, and any civil officers to be impeached for "treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors."
  4. What are the reasons for the impeachments of the 5 most recent judicial impeachments?
    Four of the five justices were impeached after being convicted of certain crimes. For Harry Claiborne, the crime was falsifying income tax returns. Alcee Hastings was first impeached after a for receiving a 150k bribe from the mob to reduce prison sentences for their members. However, he was acquitted in a criminal court and became a judge again. After a second investigation, which convited Hastings of perjury and obstruction of justice, he was impeached again. For Walter Nixon, the crime was perjury. For Samuel Kent, it was obstruction of justice and sexual abuse of female employees. G. Thomas Porteous was the only one impeached without a crime, but the Department of Justice discovered he had accepted bribes and failed to recuse himself cases involving those who bribed him.
  5. Why does the current makeup of the Senate make it unlikely that Supreme Court justices Kavanaugh or Thomas would be removed if impeached today?
    The Senate is controlled by Republicans, some of whom enthusiastically support Kavanaugh, and it is unlikely enough would shift to support Kavanaugh's impeachment. 
  6. Why is it hard to tell which offenses are "impeachable offenses" for a justice?
    There is no definition in the Constitution for a "high crime or misdemeanor." Precedent shows that it is not necessarily an action which disgraces an office. Thus, ultimately Congress decides the definition of "impeachable offense".

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Purge the Scourge

1.  What was Lt Colonol Alexander Vindman's job in the bureaucracy? He was a top Ukraine expert on the National Security Council. 2. What did Vindman testify during the impeachment investigation? He testified that, while listening in on Trump's call with Zelensky, he found the call inappropriate and that Trump should not have asked Ukraine to investigate Biden, a political opponent of Trump. 3. What did the White House do to Vindman and his brother? Vindman was removed from his post and detailed to the Defense Department; his brother was reassigned. 4. How is the White House justifying this action? The White House claimed this was just part of a larger shrinking of the National Security Counsel staff. 5. Why does the author argue that this creates a danger for other civil servants? Other officials are even more scared to testify against the president should he act inappropriately again. 6. What was Gordon Sondland's job in the Trump Administration? He was th...

Dining Democrats

1. Why is the Liberty and Justice Celebration dinner important to candidates? It is one of the final occasions at which the Democratic candidates can push for support and re-energize their base before the caucuses begin. 2. What percentage of voters still consider themselves undecided?  What percentage of voters are currently certain of their choice in candidates? 29% are still undecided. Only 20% are certain. 3. Which candidates are seeing an increase in support? Which candidates are seeing a decrease in support? Warren and Buttigieg have seen increases in support, while Biden and Sanders have seen their support decrease. 4. What message does Pete Buttigieg use to try to stand out to voters? Buttigieg seeks to cast himself as a centrist and sought to emphasize his connection to Obama, as he had once been a volunteer for Obama's campaign. 5. What message does Elizabeth Warren use to try to stand out to voters? Warren emphasized her progressive policies, such as h...

A Stroll Through the Polls

1. The seven most recent polls they looked at measured opinion about last weekend (Those covering Jan 19 in the polling dates).  How many showed more support for removing Trump than opposition for removing Trump? All 7 found more support for removing Trump that opposition. 2. Which of these 7 polls found the most support for removing Trump? Which found the most opposition to removing Trump? The FiveThirtyEight/Ipsos poll found the most support for removing Trump (54%). The Monmouth poll found the most opposition to removing him (48%). 3. In FiveThirtyEight's polling average, what percentage of Democrats support removing Trump from office? What percentage of Republicans support removing Trump from office? 83.9% of Democrats support removing Trump from office. Only 8.4% of Republicans support removing him. 4. What difference did the most recent Monmouth University poll find in the people who say they support removing Trump from office and those who support the House impeachi...